ENG 100-I
Machine Culture: our technology, our selves
Spring 2015 M –W 2:30-3:45 Duffy 117
CRN: 40767
Prof. Peek
Office:
Cushing-Martin 123
Email:
wpeek@stonehill.edu
Office hours: Wednesdays 1-2:15 until Spring Break: Wednesdays 4-5:30
after Spring Break; I am also available most Mondays 11:30-1:00 and Fridays
after 2:30. Please confirm office
hour visits via email.
Class blog:
http://machineculture.blogspot.com
Is your Smart
Phone making you dumber? Is your Roomba innocently vacuuming by day while
plotting world domination by night? When you hear a machine beeping and you
jump to respond, is the machine serving you or are you serving it? As
Artificial Intelligence expert Josh Hall frames the issue, if we can program a
robot that will be more moral than humans, should we then allow it to rule us?
This class
explores the representation of technology, both technophilic and technophobic
visions, as created by artists from ancient Athens to the 21st century. The
questions we pursue will include: to what extent is technology the friend or
foe of humanity? Will machines enable our perfection or enhance our flaws?
Would it be better if our machines were more or less like us?
Our primary method
of analysis will be close-reading, a technique that demands careful attention
to the details of literary language as we read familiar texts in new contexts.
Our guiding question: as we study these older works as parables about
technology, what will we newly see in them and in ourselves?
This class is 3
credits, which means that you are expected to put in 6-9 hours per week outside
of class for preparation. Your daily responsibilities include coming to class
on time every day with the materials assigned for discussion (or notes from
your readings) and with the assignment completed.
NOTE: The class-determined penalty for not bringing assigned reading to class will be that the violator must …
Required Texts:
In the Stonehill
Bookstore:
Aeschylus. Prometheus Bound. Oxford
U. P. ISBN: 0195061659
Shakespeare, William. The
Tempest. New Folger
Library. ISBN: 0743482832
Wells, H. G. The War of the Worlds. Penguin. ISBN-10: 0141441038
On Reserve:
Asimov, Isaac, “Bicentennial
Man” (available on Aress)
Blade Runner: Final Cut (dir. Ridley Scott, 2007; streaming
on Ares)
Brynjolfsson, Erik and Andrew
McAfee, Race Against the Machine, (Digital
Frontier Press, 2012), chapter 2 (ERes)
her (dir. Spike Jonze, 2014; streaming
on Ares)
Kurzweil, Ray. The Age of
Intelligent Machines (MIT Press, 1992), Intro and Chapter 5, “Mechanical
Roots” (Ares).
Little Red Riding Hood (dir. David
Kaplan, 1997; on regular reserve)
Plug & Pray (dir.
Jens Schanze, 2010; on regular reserve)
The Terminator (dir. James
Cameron, 1984; streaming on Ares)
DAILY SCHEDULE:
Please note that
the pop quizzes will expect you to know vocabulary from the readings.
Thus, it is your task to look up and learn vocabulary that is not
familiar to you. In addition, pop quizzes may cover all the materials you're
asked to read or view before class, and may ask you about the arguments of the
material you read.
Key
terms for assigned work:
Read for class or View
for class means that you need to read this material before class meets to
discuss it.
In-class work or View
in class means that I will introduce the material or we will read it
together in class.
Discussion questions are
questions that you should think about and jot down notes for, with relevant
page numbers, before class, but you will not need to turn in your answers.
Note,
too, that I reserve the right to alter the syllabus during the course of the
semester.
M Jan 12
Review Syllabus
Read for class: “There will come soft rains” from The Martian Chronicles (PDF emailed)
W Jan 14
Representation 1: Form and Content
M Jan 19
No class; MLK Day
W Jan 21
Representation 2: Representation and Metaphor
“In-class Metaphor Exercise”
Quiz on Syllabus
M Jan 26
Representation 3: Metonymy, synecdoche, and writing about
poetry
Homework to turn in: Read the “Representation and
Figurative Language” page link on the class blog. Using the subordinate and superordinate method we’ve learned
in class, diagram the poem by Hughes that you find there.
W Jan 28
Snow Day
M Feb 2
Snow Day
W Feb 4
Representation 4: Poetry
Homework to turn in: “Homework Assignment for Representation Day 4”
Hand out poems for Paper #1
Sign up in class to workshop
M Feb 9
Snow Day
W Feb 11 NOTE: You need to do the assignment for Monday, Feb 9
Homework to turn in: “Homework Assignment on Vendler and ‘Praise in Summer’”
Read for class: Jacob and Wilhelm Grimm, “Little Red-Cap” (in packet)
View for class: Little Red Riding Hood, dir. David Kaplan, 1997; available on reserve
NOTE: this film is only about 12 minutes long. You can also find it on YouTube.
Prepare for class: a list of the differences in form and content (2 lists) between the Grimm and Kaplan versions of the Little Red Riding Hood story.
In-class work: Discuss how formal changes affect interpretation in "Little Red Riding Hood."
Work through "Praise in Summer," "The School Children," "This Be the Verse."
In-class work: Discuss how formal changes affect interpretation in "Little Red Riding Hood."
Work through "Praise in Summer," "The School Children," "This Be the Verse."
UNIT 1: Machine Natives?
M February 16
Read for class: Prometheus Bound to p. 62 AND the following essays in the "Introduction" section: "I: the Myth," (p. 3ff.), and "II: The Prometheus Bound" (p. 6ff.). Don't worry if you don't understand everything in these essays, but they'll still provide you with useful information. Note: in my email I said you'd read one introductory essay but it's two--sorry. Both really are necessary for your understanding of the play.
Helpful Hint: Make full use of the “Notes” and “Glossary” at the end; they explain many elements that may be unclear.
Discussion Questions (jot down answers to bring to class & cite SPECIFIC PASSAGES for your answers):
Who is Prometheus? (see notes at back of book) How is he characterized? That is, what does his manner of speaking reveal about his character, and what do other characters say about him?
Who is Hephaistos (in 1st 4 pages)? What does his manner of speaking reveal about his character, and what do other characters say about him?
Who is Zeus? What does his manner of speaking reveal about his character, and what do other characters say about him?
Who is Ocean? What does his manner of speaking reveal about his character, and what do other characters say about him?
Who is Io (beginning p. 55)? What does her manner of speaking reveal about her character, and what do other characters say about her?
Discuss in class: Key words and body paragraphs with Paul Fussell
W Feb 18
Read for class:
1. Prometheus Bound to end
2. "Daedalus & Icarus" from Ovid, Metamorphoses (in packet). Note: if the Ovid passage is maddeningly obscure, look up "Minotaur" in the search engine at theoi.com. Feel free to poke around the site to learn more about the characters in this story.
View for class: Frontline: "Digital Nation" (Feb. 2, 2010). Watch at least the first 26 minutes (until the end of the Korean song).
Optional viewing:
Homework to complete for class: Bring one typed paragraph to class in answer to each of these questions (one paragraph for each):
1. The Icarus story is often taught as a moral tale about listening to one’s parents. What details in the story support that reading? Quote them.
2. If we were to read this story as being about new technologies, which details would we focus on to support that reading? Quote them.
Discuss in class: Integrating quotations
M Feb 23
Paper #1 Due –Workshoppers: Zoe, Sierra, Arielle
NOTE: If you are workshopping your paper on Feb. 25, meet in Duffy 206 during our regularly scheduled class time (2:30). Everyone else, come to class with your papers in their folders.
Paper #1 Due –Workshoppers: Zoe, Sierra, Arielle
NOTE: If you are workshopping your paper on Feb. 25, meet in Duffy 206 during our regularly scheduled class time (2:30). Everyone else, come to class with your papers in their folders.
W Feb 25
Paper #1 Due--Workshoppers: Meggie, Alexandra, Chinthu, Conor, Leonardo
NOTE: If you turned in or workshopped your paper on Feb. 23, meet in Duffy 118 during our regularly scheduled class time (2:30).
NOTE: If you turned in or workshopped your paper on Feb. 23, meet in Duffy 118 during our regularly scheduled class time (2:30).
UNIT 2: Machine Love
M March 2
View for class: "Be Right Back" Black Mirror, Season 2, Ep. 1
Read for class: E. M. Forester, “The Machine Stops” (packet)
Resource People: Alex, Zoe, Arielle
Homework to turn in: write a paragraph in answer to any one of the discussion questions on RH of blog. (Resource People are exempt from this requirement--and should not even look at the questions.)
Homework to turn in: write a paragraph in answer to any one of the discussion questions on RH of blog. (Resource People are exempt from this requirement--and should not even look at the questions.)
W Mar 4
View for class: her (dir. Spike Jonze, 2014, Ares)
Read for class: Bradbury, "The Long Years" (PDF)
Resource People: Michelle, Mary
Homework to turn in: write a paragraph in answer to any one of the discussion questions (Resource People are exempt from this requirement--and should not even look at the questions)
Resource People: Michelle, Mary
Homework to turn in: write a paragraph in answer to any one of the discussion questions (Resource People are exempt from this requirement--and should not even look at the questions)
M Mar 9 Spring Break
W Mar 11 Spring Break
Unit 3: Machine Fear
“I for one welcome our new computer overlords."
Ken Jennings, Jeopardy player after being beaten by computer Watson
M Mar 16
Intro to Modernity
Clip show: Modern Times
Read for class:
1. Erik Brynjolfsson and Andrew McAfee, Race Against the Machine, chapter 2 (Ares)
2. In packet: “Unit 4: the Technology of Modernity.” These readings include: page titled FYS 113 on Pastoralism, etc.; a reading from The Culture of Time and Space.
W Mar 18
Read for class: The War of the Worlds, to p. 30
Discussion Questions:
1. Do you see pastoral ideas represented in the novel?
2. What aspects of late 19th century technology are represented in the novel? Are they represented in a positive way? A negative way? Some other way?
3. Consider the location at the start of the novel (see the map at the back). Why does Wells begin the story here, rather than in a city, the symbol par excellence of modernity?
Review topics for paper #2
Review topics for paper #2
M Mar 23
Read for Class: The War of the Worlds, to p. 112 (through Book 1)
Resource People: Andreas and Nick
W Mar 25
Prof out sick
M Mar 30
Read for class: The War of the Worlds, to end
Resource People: David and Chris
W April 1
View for class: The Terminator (available on Ares)
Resource People: Conor, Connor, Andrew
Homework (not to turn in): Look at (you don't have to turn in anything) the discussion questions for The Terminator. Think about how you might answer these questions. (Resource People are exempt from this requirement--and should not even look at the questions)
Paper #2 due: Workshoppers: Gloria, Julianne
If you are a workshopper on Apr. 2, watch Plug & Pray. Everyone else, come to class with your papers in their folders.
EASTER BREAK
M April 6 Magical Monday
Paper #2 due: Workshoppers: Michelle, Hal, Connor, Chris, Hailee, Mary
Unit 4: Robo sapiens: Machine Intelligence
W April 8 (follow
Monday Schedule)
View for class: Plug & Pray. The DVD is on reserve in the library (not on Ares). You can also watch it at Hulu: http://www.hulu.com/watch/480764 (dir. Jens Schanze, 2010). BUT: try watch this in one sitting (it's about 2 hours long). Otherwise Hulu will let you play this only on Hulu Plus, unless you delete the Hulu cookie and try re-loading the film.
Read for class:
1. Ray Kurzweil, The Age of Intelligent Machines, Intro and Chapter 5, “Mechanical Roots” (Ares)
2. The New York Times, "Failing like a buggy whip maker?" Jan. 9, 2010.
Listen to for class: RadioLab: “Talking to Machines” Season 10, Ep. 1
Write to turn in in class: in two typed paragraphs, write about the content and form of Plug & Pray.
1. Content: did the film present a distinct point of view on the issue of artificial intelligence? If so, what was that view?
2. Form: picking one or two scenes, how does the film’s representation of either an individual or a particular space shape your interpretation of them?
M April 13
View for class: Blade Runner (dir. Ridley Scott, 1982, Ares)
Resource People: Patrick, Hal, Mary Kate
NO homework questions!
W Apr 15
Read for class: Asimov, “Bicentennial Man” (available on Ares)
Resource People: Megan, Gloria, Leonardo
UNIT 5: MASTERS OF THE MACHINE
"Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic."
Arthur C. Clarke
M April 20
Read for class: The Tempest, Acts 1-2
W Apr 22
Read for class: The Tempest, Act 3
Resource People: Sierra, Meggie, Hailee
M Apr 27
Paper #3 due: workshoppers: Patrick, Mary Kate, Andrew, Nick
If you are a workshopper on Apr. 27, finish reading The Tempest. Everyone else, come to class with your papers in their folders.
W Apr 29
Paper #3 due: workshoppers: Austin, David, Andreas, Megan
F May 1 Magical Monday
Read for class: The Tempest, to end
“The day I confronted my troll,” Leo Traynor, The Guardian, September 26,
2012
Resource People: Julianne, Chinthu, Austin
In-class writing: why does Prospero give up his magic? What does and doesn't the text tell us?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
AND POLICIES:
Assignments and Grades:
Everyone in the
class writes three papers that compose 50% of the final grade (with an extra 5%
going to the paper with the best grade). Work as a resource person,
contributions to GroupMe, and strong participation generally will compose 15% of your final
grade. The grades from five of the six (or more) pop quizzes (the lowest grade
is dropped) compose 15% of the final grade. The final exam (with essay section)
is worth 15%.
Papers and Quizzes:
Format:
1) Format your
papers with 1" margins on all sides, double-spaced, and fonts no larger
than 12 point (scaled roughly to Times New Roman size). Cover sheets are a
waste of paper, but a thoughtful title is always appreciated.
2) It is not
necessary to provide a “Works Cited” page for assigned readings. If you use
materials not explicitly assigned in class, cite them using MLA Style (the
basics are parenthetical references with a Works Cited page). When in doubt,
use one of the “Recommended Sites for Grammar, Usage, and Punctuation,”
available at a link on the right.
3) When you turn
in your papers, put them in your folder and make sure that all previous course
work, including drafts and other papers, are included in the notebook. You will not receive a grade on a paper until
you turn in the originals of your previous papers in their folder, with my
comments.
General Policies:
1) The grade on
late papers will drop 10 points per calendar day that the paper is late. A
paper is considered late if it is turned in after the start of class on
the day it is due.
2) If illness
prevents you from turning a paper in on time, email me as soon as possible, and we’ll make
appropriate arrangements. If you have a computer draft of a paper, you may
email that to me on the due date.
3) You must
complete all of the assignments to pass the class (even if they are turned in
so late that they cannot receive a passing grade).
5) Pop quizzes
cannot be made up. If you're absent on the day of a pop quiz, that quiz
will be one of your dropped quiz grades.
Procedures:
1) Once a
semester, you will workshop one of your papers in class. That is, you will read
a draft of your paper to the class and they will make suggestions directed
toward making it a stronger paper. You can then take their verbal comments and
turn in a final draft of the paper due a week after the day of the workshop.
You can continue to work with me polishing the paper even after it is workshopped.
The logistics: when it’s your turn to workshop, email your paper to me by 10 am the
afternoon they’re due, and I will make copies of the paper for the class to
read.
Do not miss class on the day your paper is to be workshopped. Your grade on the paper will drop by 10 points, and you will miss the benefit of feedback from your peers.
See the link on the RH side of the blog for detailed instructions on workshopping and serving as a Resource Person.
Do not miss class on the day your paper is to be workshopped. Your grade on the paper will drop by 10 points, and you will miss the benefit of feedback from your peers.
See the link on the RH side of the blog for detailed instructions on workshopping and serving as a Resource Person.
2) I encourage you
to bring rough drafts to my office hours for discussion. Sometimes we can have
even more productive meetings if several class members come at the initial
stage of thesis development. I cannot
read emailed drafts unless I specifically ask for them.
Grading Guidelines: I give out numerical rather than alphabetical grades. The scale is:
97 = A+
93 = A
90 = A-
87 = B+
83 = B
80 = B-
77 = C+
73 = C
70 = C-
67 = D+
63 = D
60 = D-
59 & below = F
F = You fail to
turn in the paper, or your paper lacks a thesis, or you have no arguments or
evidence in defense of your thesis. Simply completing the work does not
guarantee a passing grade.
D = A thesis with
some supporting arguments and examples/quotations. A “D” signifies serious
problems with the organization of the argument (weak topic sentences,
unconvincing examples, no transitions between ideas) and/or with expression
(diction, wordiness, poor grammar, mechanical errors, lack of necessary specifics).
C = A clear
thesis, with some convincing supporting arguments with examples/quotations. Some
acknowledgment of relevant objections, if appropriate. A “C” indicates that
there are problems with organization and/or developments of the thesis,
although the writing may be clear and the argument convincing.
B = A clear
thesis, with fully developed and convincing supporting arguments. Appropriate
and helpful examples/quotations. Careful attention to details of expression,
whether verbal or visual. Sensitivity to the subtleties of the text. You
demonstrate that you are a careful reader as well as a competent writer.
Consideration and refutation of relevant objections, if appropriate. Free of
mechanical errors.
A = Everything
required for a B, plus significant, original thought. The thesis and analysis
in an “A” paper are sophisticated, complex, subtle. In particular, the work
with quotations closely reads and builds on the ideas in the quotations.
Attendance Policy:
Attend every
class. We have a lot of ground to cover in a very short amount of time. If you become ill during the semester, send me
an email immediately. Please find a friendly face in class to take notes
for you and to collect or turn in any handouts or assignments that are due.
If you encounter
circumstances that make it difficult to abide by this policy, come and talk to
me. An excessive number of absences will have a deleterious effect on your
final grade. It is necessary, though not sufficient, that you attend at least
75% of the classes for a passing grade.
Diversity and inclusion: Stonehill College embraces
the diversity of students, faculty, and staff, honors the inherent dignity of
each individual, and welcomes their unique cultural and religious experiences,
beliefs, and perspectives. We all benefit from
a diverse living and learning environment, and the sharing of differences in
ideas, experiences, and beliefs help us shape our own
perspectives. Course content and campus discussions will heighten your
awareness to these differences.
The Office of Intercultural Affairs (Duffy 149) serves as an accessible resource to anyone
seeking support or with questions about diversity and inclusion at Stonehill.
If you are a witness to or experience acts of bias at Stonehill or would like
to learn more about how we address bias incidents, please email diversity@stonehill.edu.
English Department Policy on
Plagiarism
In support of Stonehill
College's Academic Integrity Policy, the English Department requires that its
faculty notify the Director of Academic Services about every student who has
plagiarized or violated the Academic Honor Code in any manner. All
members of the College community have the responsibility to be familiar with
and to follow the College's policy on academic integrity. Since the
actions that constitute violation of the policy are covered in many
places, including The Hill Book and in presentations at orientation, pleading
ignorance will not work. If you have questions about what constitutes a
violation of the code or how to incorporate outside sources in your work,
please consult with your professor before you turn in your assignment.
Academic Integrity:
My expectation is that you will
adhere to the Academic Honor Code and Academic Integrity Policy, which can be
accessed in the Academic Policies section of the 2014-2015 Hill Book.
(From the The Hill Book): Academic dishonesty includes
but is not limited to the following actions:
1. Presenting another's work as if it were one's own;
2. Failing
to acknowledge or document a source even if the action is unintended (i.e.,
plagiarism);
[N. B. This can take various
forms: 1) using the writer's exact words without proper punctuation and citation; 2) paraphrasing the argument without
crediting the author; 3) providing a paraphrase that is too close to the
original—even if you cite the author; 4) even following the general outline or
drift of the argument without indicating the source of the idea];
3. Giving or receiving, or attempting to give or receive, unauthorized assistance or information in an assignment or examination
4.
Fabricating data;
5.
Submitting the same assignment in two or more courses without prior
permission of the respective instructors;
6. Having
another person write a paper or sit for an examination;
7.
Unauthorized use of electronic devices to complete work; or
8.
Furnishing false information, including lying or fabricating excuses, for
incomplete work.
Because we have reviewed in
class what constitutes academic honesty, we will not consider ignorance of the
rules to be a valid excuse. A
violation of Stonehill’s
Academic Integrity Policy will result in a failing grade for the course.
When in doubt, always verify with me if something is being done properly or is allowable in this class rather than simply make an assumption based on the fact that it was or is currently allowable in another class.
Students with
documented disabilities: Stonehill College is
committed to providing all students equal access to learning opportunities. The
Office of Disability Services works with students who have disabilities to
provide and/or arrange reasonable accommodations.
Students registered with the
Office of Disability Services are encouraged to self-advocate and contact their
professors as soon as possible, preferably prior to the start of the semester,
to inform them of the accommodations for which they qualify.
Students are responsible for
providing their professors with an accommodations verification letter from the
Office of Disability Services and discussing their needs with them.
Students who have, or think they may have, a disability
are invited to contact the Office of Disability Services for a confidential
appointment at (50
